Last year I didn’t get a chance to write about the Halloween Candy and Wine pairing so this year a few faithful readers reminded me that I needed to get tasting! So, armed with a few bags of candy and a few bottles of wine I set out to come up with the best Halloween candy and wine pairing this year.

In past years we have paired dark chocolate Hershey Kisses with a dry red wine but this year I was on a mission to find a new option. I selected one of our latest releases at the winery – a Cabernet Franc and started to pair it with some unusual candies (Nerds, Swedish Fish, Tootsie Rolls) but wasn’t impressed with how it manipulated the taste of the wine. Just when I was about to cheat and select M&Ms to pair with our Cab Franc, I selected a Twix bar. I was actually surprised that the caramel from the Twix mellowed out the oak flavors of the wine.

I debated about what to try with the next candy – Skittles. I knew anything sweet would not pair well with the Skittles so I started with a Riesling. The fruity flavors of the Skittles still overpowered the wine so I paired them with our unoaked Chardonnay. Between the crisp flavor of the Chardonnay and the fruity Skittles candy, I think I found a great  match!

The next candy was a fun one to pair – Reeses Peanut Butter Cups. This is my favorite candy of all time! How could you pass up the texture combination of smooth chocolate and creamy peanut butter? In past years I have loved to pair our Riesling with a nutty flavor. So I instantly put these two together and was excited to find a winner!

As my tasting started to wind down I tried the final candy and my husband’s favorite – candy corn. I am not a fan of candy corn nor am I a fan of sweet wines; however the combination of the candy corn and our Afterglow (a sweet red) was a surprising combination. The pairing of the two toned down the sweetness in both the candy and the wine.

Disappointed that I did not find anything to pair with our fruit wines (Cranberry and Raspberry) I decided to experiment with some other options. After trying a few combinations of candy and our Raspberry wine, I came up with a great Halloween treat. I had to include dark chocolate somewhere in my pairing so my new favorite pairing is dark chocolate M&Ms with a glass of Raspberry wine. Happy Halloween everyone!

Amanda is the Co-Owner of Candlelight Winery located at 11325 Center Road, Garrettsville. For more information on the winery, please visit

Previous articleMemorial Trash
Next articleRiding Out This Volatile Market
Amanda Conkol and her husband Chris are the owners of Candlelight Winery in Garrettsville, Ohio. Amanda’s passion for wine is evident in her weekly column “Notes From The Vineyard”, but that’s not all Amanda is passionate about. She maintains a full schedule raising twin daughters, working a day job consulting as an IT Project Manager and is the Girl Troop Leader for her daughters’ troop. When time allows Amanda loves to travel (especially to Disney World) and go for runs throughout Nelson Township.